|
|
Post by Astral Echo on Jan 28, 2007 4:58:18 GMT -5
I know 4ver will comfirm Paige, I know she's itching to reply to that message. However Coop will not be in the show. As for children we are not revealing any information, we have a little trick up our sleave, we're very evil we can tell you that.
|
|
|
|
Post by Fourever Charmed on Jan 28, 2007 9:53:18 GMT -5
So far it an amazing story and it was rather touching when Leo & Piper lit a candle for their daughter. I was just wondering/curious whether or not paige would either be with agent brody or henry and Pheobe with either cole or coop and also will Leo and Piper have a baby girl named Prudence or Melinda of course wyatt and chris right?? Thanks for leaving this one to me, Dan!  I can tell you right now that Brody will not be on C:RR. As for Henry, we can't tell you that yet. Right now we're just working with one on-off love interest, which is Glenn. But I can tell you that Paige will have other boyfriends, because where's the fun in saddling her with one guy for the whole series? After all, Piper alreadt has Leo and Phoebe has Cole, and Prue appears to have Matt, so we need a little flavor in the boyfriends category if you know what I mean. |
|
|
|
Post by Astral Echo on Jan 28, 2007 12:40:58 GMT -5
I know you were just itching to comment anyway and Paige is your area of expertise so I thought I should leave her to you.
|
|
|
|
Post by jodi282 on Jan 28, 2007 13:16:25 GMT -5
Thank you I was just wondering if we will see Whitlighter Andy hopefully sometime in the future?
|
|
|
|
Post by Fourever Charmed on Jan 28, 2007 21:49:39 GMT -5
Thank you I was just wondering if we will see Whitlighter Andy hopefully sometime in the future? I know how much you guys want Andy back, because I'm a huge Andy fan myself. Now I know I can't speak for the rest of the staff, but I can't stand the idea of Andy as a whitelighter, though. I mean, it would be great to see him and Prue together again, but we already have a whitelighter/witch romance. (Two, actually, if you count Pam [Patty/Sam]].) And then if you include kids later down the line, I think it's just a little tacky to have a whole brood of little orbers. |
|
xrs
Innocent
Semper Charmed
Posts: 25
|
Post by xrs on Jan 29, 2007 13:27:28 GMT -5
And now the comments...
I originally thought that 4.11 was going to be a great episode. Anybody with half a brain could see (almost literally see) that. That turned out to be a big mistake. The episode exceeded by far my expectations, proving that no matter how much certain executive producers try to shake our belief in the capacity of Man to fulfill even the most basic of functions (CONTINUITY and SENCE) upon undertaking the task of writing a script, the human spirit moves on, OVER them. And 4.11 had much more in it than just the basics...
It had the characters as all of us think they should be. Piper's fustrations reaching their inevitable, exeptionally played out cressendo. Prue being... Prue, depentable and to the point, a magnificent queen of sarcasm. And Paige, "young witch", but not the portrait of an idiot, as someone "made" her to be, offering the only logical way out of this perdicament: Forgiveness. And Phoebe... emotional but not self-centered, as an empath (yes, she will earn the right to be one in C:RR, if she goes on like that) of her sister's feelings, but like a mountain remaining between her and her pray. The other characters were all great, too. The Oracle... Cole... and of course Leo (not Piper's-accessory-idiot). I'm not elaborating more, because then this "comment" will be endless...
The plot was, in many ways, surprising. I know you can't give away your end of this season, but what exactly does the Oracle want with Phoebe? Why do I get the feeling that there's more to that book of prophecies and in particular in that "skies and rain" prophecy? Is my suspicion valid? But more questions about the "larger picture" later...
Episode 4.12 was great, very well played, very dramatic. The cat's out of the bag, now. What is "miss stuborness", a.k.a. Prue going to do now, with a witch boyfriend who "lied" to her, no less. That should be interesting... And a very well acted Phoebe-Paige subplot.
By the way, I think that no matter what will happen in the future with Prue's love life, Matt should definetely be "her man". Andy was a great character, but there were too many emotional "clashes" and baggage for that relationship to work, even if he was alive.
Summary? Allow me to express to you all, C:RR staff and associates, my sincere admiration for a series "very well done". It was all I expected, sometimes even more. Your dedication is commendable. I wish you the best.
|
|
|
|
Post by ella07 on Jan 29, 2007 17:33:09 GMT -5
I just joined so I could post some feedback about the episodes. I love reading them all and they would be great on TV.
I've just finished 4.11 and I loved reading it so much! The enemies were written so well, they could've been in series 1 or 2 on TV! I hope Piper gets some happiness in her life again soon. Nice to see Cole is featured quite a lot like in the books. I like that you inserted some extra realism with the death of Piper's unborn child. I'm not usually very good with feedback or I don't write much, but I will continue reading and telling of bits I liked.
|
|
|
|
Post by Fourever Charmed on Jan 29, 2007 20:09:32 GMT -5
And now the comments... I originally thought that 4.11 was going to be a great episode. Anybody with half a brain could see (almost literally see) that. That turned out to be a big mistake. The episode exceeded by far my expectations, proving that no matter how much certain executive producers try to shake our belief in the capacity of Man to fulfill even the most basic of functions (CONTINUITY and SENCE) upon undertaking the task of writing a script, the human spirit moves on, OVER them. And 4.11 had much more in it than just the basics... It had the characters as all of us think they should be. Piper's fustrations reaching their inevitable, exeptionally played out cressendo. Prue being... Prue, depentable and to the point, a magnificent queen of sarcasm. And Paige, "young witch", but not the portrait of an idiot, as someone "made" her to be, offering the only logical way out of this perdicament: Forgiveness. And Phoebe... emotional but not self-centered, as an empath (yes, she will earn the right to be one in C:RR, if she goes on like that) of her sister's feelings, but like a mountain remaining between her and her pray. The other characters were all great, too. The Oracle... Cole... and of course Leo (not Piper's-accessory-idiot). I'm not elaborating more, because then this "comment" will be endless... The plot was, in many ways, surprising. I know you can't give away your end of this season, but what exactly does the Oracle want with Phoebe? Why do I get the feeling that there's more to that book of prophecies and in particular in that "skies and rain" prophecy? Is my suspicion valid? But more questions about the "larger picture" later... Episode 4.12 was great, very well played, very dramatic. The cat's out of the bag, now. What is "miss stuborness", a.k.a. Prue going to do now, with a witch boyfriend who "lied" to her, no less. That should be interesting... And a very well acted Phoebe-Paige subplot. By the way, I think that no matter what will happen in the future with Prue's love life, Matt should definetely be "her man". Andy was a great character, but there were too many emotional "clashes" and baggage for that relationship to work, even if he was alive. Summary? Allow me to express to you all, C:RR staff and associates, my sincere admiration for a series "very well done". It was all I expected, sometimes even more. Your dedication is commendable. I wish you the best. Wow, that is some of the best feedback I've ever received. (I actually read your post four times.) Thank you so much for taking the time to type that up. It means so much to hear comments like that. I can't comment a lot on our plot with The Oracle, but I will say that each one of us has put an enormous amount of work into each episode. (As it should be. I was just telling Jackie [Drama!] last night how I've done more Googling in the past few weeks that I've ever done before, for the purpose of realism [so actual research like getting the dates down to the days of the week correct, specific to 2001/2002 calendars] and continuity.) I will say that detail should be closely examined, because there are so many things that one is likely to miss until the big picture is revealed. ( Everything is working towards a deliberate storyline, as the team has spent numerous hours mapping out a coherent plot.) I just joined so I could post some feedback about the episodes. I love reading them all and they would be great on TV. I've just finished 4.11 and I loved reading it so much! The enemies were written so well, they could've been in series 1 or 2 on TV! I hope Piper gets some happiness in her life again soon. Nice to see Cole is featured quite a lot like in the books. I like that you inserted some extra realism with the death of Piper's unborn child. I'm not usually very good with feedback or I don't write much, but I will continue reading and telling of bits I liked. Well I know I speak for all of us when I say that even the smallest comments mean a lot to us, so thank you for posting your thoughts.  I always love to hear someone say that they can visual something on television, because I feel like we've made it very "real" for the viewer. And Cole, yes, he's an extraordinary character. (I've always been very bitter about how the show's writers destroyed his character, which held so much promise and potential. So since we're writing the wrongs, he's definitely going to be something that he never got the chance to be in Kern's world.) |
|
|
|
Post by Astral Echo on Jan 30, 2007 4:07:34 GMT -5
Thankyou both for your comments, it's always nice to hear what people think, critism aswell and not just I liked it, we want to know why. And you both did that and by the looks of it I'm guessing your liking Matt xrs, that was always going to be tough bridge, another man filling Andy's shoes. It's like if we suddenly killed Leo off (that we arn't it's just an example) and then brang in another man it would be hard for us to get the character to win the viewers over. And hopefully we have done that with Matt.
As 4ver said, realism and continuaty is the key, even the best plots and episodes can be ruined by characters being the exact opposite from what they have been or messing with facts, dates etc... It all adds to the realism, something Kern couldn't do, consintatly (SP) changing the rules (Freezing good witches for example) and not be true to real life, sure it's a fantasy show but there has to be some trueness, after all the sisters were human sisters before sister witches!
And Cole, as 4ver said we promise you we will not ruin his character or push him to the sidelines. Unfortunatly because of establishing Paige and Matt in the show we kind of forgot slightly about Cole and Leo, there are episodes where they haven't appear at all I think! Though we wish to change that, I know the next few episodes Cole will be a big part of.
|
|
|
|
Post by Drama on Jan 30, 2007 12:43:46 GMT -5
Or Leo will be doing his whitelighter duties......................  |
|
|
|
Post by ella07 on Feb 3, 2007 8:01:26 GMT -5
Just finished reading episode 12, I couldn't stop reading until it finished. Each episode seems to be even better than the last (and they are all great). I have a suspicion about Matt because there are shades of when Chris Perry in Matt due to what happened in 12. I have no idea what the truth is tho and it will still be a surprise what the truth is when you reveal it. I wish you could post episode 13 today.
|
|
|
|
Post by Drama on Feb 3, 2007 11:50:49 GMT -5
It's great to hear what people think about Matt because he's an original character created by Dan and modified by us all.
|
|
|
|
Post by Domino on Feb 3, 2007 13:25:26 GMT -5
Personally, I hope he dies. No offence, I just think he's what everyone wants for the sisters. A witch lover. And he seems to be just like when Cole came in. But good.
|
|
|
|
Post by Fourever Charmed on Feb 3, 2007 13:29:56 GMT -5
Personally, I hope he dies. No offence, I just think he's what everyone wants for the sisters. A witch lover. And he seems to be just like when Cole came in. But good. None taken. I'm glad you're honest about that. |
|
|
|
Post by Drama on Feb 3, 2007 13:31:16 GMT -5
If all characters were well liked, it wouldn't be any fun.
|
|
I always love to hear someone say that they can visual something on television, because I feel like we've made it very "real" for the viewer. And Cole, yes, he's an extraordinary character. (I've always been very bitter about how the show's writers destroyed his character, which held so much promise and potential. So since we're writing the wrongs, he's definitely going to be something that he never got the chance to be in Kern's world.)
