|
|
Post by PhoenyxAngel on Mar 17, 2008 15:42:23 GMT -5
Phoebe Halliwell - South Bracket (Play-In Games)Kill Billie: Vol 2 - Because the manor exploding is awesome. Used Karma - Because I don't like The mummy episode. Cat House - Because I like the flash backs. Witch Wars - Because the demonic reality show was a neat idea. Little Box Of Horrors - Because it was a neat episode. Witchness Protection - Charisma Carpenter, nuff said. Paige Matthews - North Bracket (Play-In Games)Styx Feet Under - Piper becomes the Angel of Death. The Courtship of Wyatt's Father - Piper and Leo get back together  Baby's First Demon - I disliked both but Baby's First Demon was better than the King Arthur episode for me. It's A Bad, Bad, Bad, Bad World - I like the evil alternate reality. Charmageddon - I really like both episodes but seeing Utopia was pretty cool. Paige Matthews - South Bracket (Play-In Games)Forever Charmed - I don't really like how it was done but it's better than a Call to Arms. Prince Charmed - Hated the Importance of Beng Phoebe The Power of Three Blondes - The Blonde Power of 3 > Nymphs. A Wrong Day's Journey to Right - Better than the fairy tale episode Scry Hard - Better than Kill Billie vol. 1 There's Something About Leo - Because I thought it was an interesting episode.
|
|
|
|
Post by nexus on Mar 17, 2008 16:38:13 GMT -5
Phoebe Halliwell - South Bracket (Play-In Games)
Kill Billie: Vol 2 vs. The Bare Witch Project
Y Tu Mummy Tambien vs. Used Karma
Cat House vs. Love's A Witch
A Witch's Tail vs. Witch Wars
Rewitched vs. Little Box Of Horrors
Repo Manor vs. Witchness Protection
Paige Matthews - North Bracket (Play-In Games)
The Torn Identity vs. Styx Feet Under
Sympathy For The Demon vs. The Courtship of Wyatt's Father
Baby's First Demon vs. Sword And The City
Malice In Wonderland v Death Becomes Them v It's A Bad, Bad, Bad, Bad World
Vaya Con Leos vs. Charmageddon
Paige Matthews - South Bracket (Play-In Games)
Forever Charmed vs. A Call to Arms
The Importance of Being Phoebe vs. Prince Charmed
Nymphs Just Want to Have Fun vs. The Power of Three Blondes
Happily Ever After vs. A Wrong Day's Journey to Right
Kill Billie: Vol 1 vs. Scry Hard
Twelve Angry Zen vs. There's Something About Leo
|
|
|
|
Post by Semi-Charming Life on Mar 17, 2008 18:48:21 GMT -5
Phoebe Halliwell - South Bracket (Play-In Games)
Kill Billie: Vol 2-A Way better episode. And way more explosive.
Y Tu Mummy Tambien-Holly's acting was amazing in this episode. NTM, Alyssa looked hot in that outfit.
Cat House-I'm a sucker for the flashbacks in this episode, even if there was some continuity errors. Like Paige suprised Phoebe was a blonde. (Makes you wonder if Paige was on crack in Season 4 since she can't remember Phoebe's hair and vanquishing the Source.) So that's what the writers were plotting to do for a storyline. Hmm.
A Witch's Tail-Lot's of freshness, and I loved the beach setting.
Little Box Of Horrors-It had great potential for a spin-off. And No Bimbo.
Witchness Protection-Charisma was in it.
Paige Matthews - North Bracket (Play-In Games)
Styx Feet Under-I loved the Paige/Piper scenes. And Death was back.
The Courtship Of Wyatt's Father-They were both good episodes. But this one had great Piper/Leo scenes.
Baby's First Demon-It was a nice episode, although a little boring that dealt with the new baby without being a whole Wyatt-is-the-king-of-Camelot crap going on.
It's A Bad, Bad, Bad, Bad World-I don't know why I'm a sucker for this episode. It felt like a nice summer to watch on a summer day. I know it wasn't better than Death Becomes Them, but it just seems to have something that keeps pulling me in.
Vaya Con Leos-In this one Leo's death sticks which makes it more emotional.
Paige Matthews - South Bracket (Play-In Games)
Forever Charmed-It's either that are watching Lesbe.
The Importance of Being Phoebe-I loved the martial arts in it, and Alyssa's comedic acting was quite funny.
The Power of Three Blondes-It was great to see a pair of sisters that were more superficial than the Charmed Ones.
A Wrong Day's Journey to Right-I loved the whole Paige going bad thing, and it had Alyssa in leather.(I know I shouldn't be sticking up for that but whatever.)
Scry Hard-It had Zankou and no Bimbo.
There's Something About Leo-Again No Bimbo. And it had explosions, Phoebe using a bat to send an energy ball back at a demon, and syco Brody.
|
|
|
|
Post by Fourever Charmed on Mar 17, 2008 19:06:44 GMT -5
I'll just post the first one for now, as I'm still deciding on the others.
Phoebe Halliwell - South Bracket (Play-In Games)
Kill Billie: Vol 2 - Holly's acting.
Y Tu Mummy Tambien - Holly was amazing, and we had Cole, and it wasn't crap.
Cat House - Prue! Okay, so it was her back, but it was still technically Prue. And, "Prue ruined Piper's wedding?!"
A Witch's Tail - Phoebe admits that she loves Cole. They'll always be meant for each other.
Little Box Of Horrors - I kind of liked Hope, even if it didn't follow previous Charmed continuity. (In "Sin Francisco," I believe Leo says that the myth of Pandora's box was started by the box of sins.)
Witchness Protection - Charisma was fun.
ETA: Numero dos.
Paige Matthews - North Bracket (Play-In Games)[/u]
Styx Feet Under - The Piper-Paige moment when Piper is walking Paige through the portal into the afterlife makes this an easy choice.
Sympathy For The Demon - I just liked it better. And Super Brat's name wasn't in the title.
Baby's First Demon - I didn't like either of them, but I'm voting this one because at least Super Brat didn't become a king in this episode.
It's A Bad, Bad, Bad, Bad World - It was really just between MIW and IABBBBW because "Death Becomes Them" was so awful (and I can't get that "I slept with a zombie" trailer out of my head). So out of the remaining two, I picked the Bad World because at least we get some kick ass Leo moments.
Vaya Con Leos - The raw emotion of Leo and Piper in this episode pwned "Charmageddon."
|
|
|
|
Post by Xenith on Mar 17, 2008 20:53:25 GMT -5
still working on mine, but I have to say:
Actually that's the thing for me that makes it a HARD choice. I HATE that scene, not the first part of it that's great and emotional, but when it comes back after the scene with Phoebe bargaining with death. Piper's annoyed "You're stalling" ignites an endless rage in me. That line is one of the single worst, out of character, complete bullsh*t lines ever uttered in this series. It's a completely heartless line that made it seem like Piper was urging her freaking sister to hurry up and move on, it was an attempt at forced comedy at the expense of realism and emotion and it just pisses me off to have Piper utter that line... It may seem a bit much, but for me that one stupid line makes an otherwise enjoyable episode completely unwatchable for me. (without an antacid)
|
|
|
|
Post by Charmed Destiny on Mar 22, 2008 15:25:16 GMT -5
Phoebe Halliwell - South Bracket (Play-In Games)
Kill Billie: Vol 2
Y Tu Mummy Tambien
Cat House
A Witch's Tail
Little Box Of Horrors
Witchness Protection
Paige Matthews - North Bracket (Play-In Games)
Styx Feet Under
Sympathy For The Demon
Baby's First Demon
It's A Bad, Bad, Bad, Bad World
Vaya Con Leos
Paige Matthews - South Bracket (Play-In Games)
Forever Charmed
The Importance of Being Phoebe
The Power of Three Blondes
Happily Ever After
Scry Hard
There's Something About Leo
|
|
|
|
Post by Xenith on Mar 25, 2008 15:40:25 GMT -5
Kill Billie: Vol 2 vs. The Bare Witch Project
One of the eps had a good dramatic ending, the other had Phoebe riding naked on a horse. Also that twit Duncan casting a P3 spell, quantum mechanics violations, and Leslie. Yeah I pretty much loathe Barewitch, so Kill Bimbo: Vol 2 it is.
Y Tu Mummy Tambien vs. Used Karma
Crazy Cole was entertaining, and then things went south. Mata Whori was not entertaining, but I really liked Jason's reaction when he found out about the Charmed Ones. (until they made him an arse that never called in later eps) So edge to Used Karma
Cat House vs. Love's A Witch
Even an episode that was only half new is better than LAW. Also SYLAR! Cat House for the win
A Witch's Tail vs. Witch Wars
Favorite part of Witch Wars was Phoebe shimmering into the bar and kicking butt. Favorite part of Brad Kern Rips Off the Little Mermaid... Yeah, there kind of isn't one. Every scene I managed to like I managed to dislike at the same time (see watercooler Morris). Vote for Witch Wars
Rewitched vs. Little Box Of Horrors
Hope was a slightly less annoying Billie in LBoH, while Billie was a more annoying Billie in Rewitched. So Little Box of Horrors it is.
Repo Manor vs. Witchness Protection
Blah I hate losing one of these rare later season gems so early. Although I thought the stealing the Power of Three plot was complete and utter BS in Repo Manor, the way they vanquished the demon when they were tiny was possibly the best vanquish ever, and the Billie bashing was absolutely classic. Yet Witchness Protection had the introduction of Zankou and was possibly his best episode, and the awesomeness of CC as Kyra. Witchness Protection must live on
The Torn Identity vs. Styx Feet Under
Voting for the sucky Torn Identity episode, that's how much I hate Piper's line...
Sympathy For The Demon vs. The Courtship of Wyatt's Father
Courtship was a nice emotional episode, and the villain that wanted to kill Leo was named Damien. Really liked Sypathy though when the Charmed Ones finallly seemingly got a clue that Cole was possessed, only for my hopes to be dashed when they went back to crapping on him instead of trying to you know...make anything resembling an attempt to save him.
Baby's First Demon vs. Sword And The City
Baby's First Demon...because that's the result I got in the eenie meenie miney mo between these two meh episodes.
Malice In Wonderland v Death Becomes Them v It's A Bad, Bad, Bad, Bad World
Malice had the worst special FX ever and was crap. Death Becomes Them had potential, but the lack of recognizable innocents as zombies and the messed up ending keep it down with the blah episodes. Phoebe got shot in Bad Bad Bad World...so winner.
Vaya Con Leos vs. Charmageddon
Another choice I hate making, I kind of like Charmageddon, but VCL was just better.
Forever Charmed vs. A Call to Arms
Barbas was vanquished by a freaking POTION in A Call to Arms. Forever Charmed may have been a timeline mess, but it didn't tick me off nearly as much as that.
The Importance of Being Phoebe vs. Prince Charmed
Importance...just because.
Nymphs Just Want to Have Fun vs. The Power of Three Blondes
Blondes was a good comedy ep, Nymphs was horrendous.
Happily Ever After vs. A Wrong Day's Journey to Right
Happily Ever After. That's what my finger landed on when I closed my eyes...
Kill Billie: Vol 1 vs. Scry Hard
Scry Hard good, Kill Billie didn't live up to it's title so...garbage.
Twelve Angry Zen vs. There's Something About Leo
Piper and the staff was comedy gold, the rest of he episode was worthless so, Something about Leo gets my vote.
|
|
|
|
Post by Xenith on Mar 25, 2008 16:29:04 GMT -5
Sudden Death Overtime:
A Wrong Day's Journey Into Right vs Happily Ever After
First new vote or changed vote decides this contest. FC you haven't cast your vote on this one yet, so you can put one out of our misery...
-----------------
In Other News:
Kill Billie Vol 2 brought the house down on The Bare Witch Project with a 7-0 shut out victory.
Y Tu Mummy Tambien sucked the life out of Used Karma (or maybe that was Eric Dane's acting) and scored a 4-3 victory.
It's Love's A Witch that's going to be living in the past after being swept by Cat House 7-0.
Witch Wars managed to Outplay Outwit and Outlast A Witch's Tail winning a 4-3 vote.
Little Box of Horrors unleashed it's sorrows upon Rewitched which had no Hope, as it was blanked 7-0
Repo Manor's tournament chances just shrunk out of existance as it falls to a swarm of votes to Witchness Protection 7-0.
The Torn Identity could not escape Death's list, as Styx Feet Under escorted it to the tournament afterlife with a 5-2 beating.
The Courtship of Wyatt's Father showed no mercy or Sympathy for the Demon as it scored the 4-3 upset.
Baby's First Demon defeated Sword in the City 7-0 in a match that SUCKED.
It's A Bad Bad Bad World for Death Becomes Them and Malice in Wonderland as they lose 6-1-0 but can't stop smiling.
It's hasta la vista for Charmageddon after it was put on ice by Vaya Con Leos by a score of 6-1.
Forever Charmed didn't need a do-over to sweep A Call to Arms 6-0
Prince Charmed has been dethroned, as The Importance of Being Phoebe lapdances it's way into the next round after a 5-1 victory.
The Nymphs fun resulted in boredom for everyone else, so The Power of Three Blondes flirts it's way to an easy 6-0 shutout.
Zankou probably could have figured out the whole Christy mystery a whole lot faster if he had been the one to read Billie's diary...just saying. Anyways, Scry Hard manged to Kill Billie with a 6-0 victory.
Twelve Angry Zen's supporters turned chicken (groan) after they were dogged (double groan) by the supporters of There's Something About Leo which paraded to 5-1 victory. Rats!
|
|
|
|
Post by Fourever Charmed on Mar 26, 2008 11:22:53 GMT -5
Okay, I thought long and hard about those two choices, and I'm going with Happily Ever After, because while it was cheesy in the sense that had all the fairytales (and another of Super Brat's super powers from the womb), it also had Grams and Cole, and I've always appreciated the line, "Hey, that's my pumpkin!" and Grams trying to get Paige to call her "Grams," which Paige finally did in the end, and those were great moments for me.
|
|
|
|
Post by Xenith on Mar 26, 2008 16:20:54 GMT -5
And with that the field of 128 is now set, and the fun can really begin. ----------- Prue Halliwell Bracket
Andy Trudeau Regionals: First Round [/u][/b][/size][/center] Something Wicca This Way Comes vs. The Last Temptation Of Christy
Bride and Gloom vs. Look Who's Barking
Reckless Abandon vs. Siren's Song
The Painted World vs. Centennial Charmed |
|
|
|
Post by Astral Echo on Mar 26, 2008 16:34:43 GMT -5
Something Wicca This Way Comes - Bimbo and her sister or Andy and Darryl. Hard decision!
Look Who's Barking - Prue dog was the sweetest and plus it was genuinely a good episode, loved Piper trying to being the solo sister too. Really great Piper/Cole moment too! "Phoebe's home!"
Siren's Song - Melinda Clarke had the sexy siren down. Loved it!
The Painted World - Not many people liked this but I loved this episode. It was just cute - Phoebe really was the baby in this episode, a baby who was trying to be grown up and kick ass!
|
|
|
|
Post by Charmed Destiny on Mar 26, 2008 17:48:44 GMT -5
Prue Halliwell Bracket
Andy Trudeau Regionals: First Round [/u][/center] Something Wicca This Way Comes - The premiere, and I just liked it more than TLTOC. Bride and Gloom - The Charmed Ones get turned into Warlocks and we get a small glimpse of how their powers would be if they were actually evil. Siren's Song - I didn't like Reckless Abandon, it didn't appeal to me, and SS was okay. Centennial Charmed - Crazy obsessive Cole dies! (I hated what they did to him in his season 5 storyline.) |
|
|
|
Post by Fourever Charmed on Mar 27, 2008 0:24:37 GMT -5
Prue Halliwell Bracket
Andy Trudeau Regionals: First Round [/center] Something Wicca This Way Comes - Given its competition, does this really need an explanation? Bride and Gloom - Probably because I'm such a huge fan of Peanut's Dream Wedding series and the whole Prue/Andy/Dantalian thing. Reckless Abandon - Hmm, Super Brat and his unborn flower power, or cute little baby Matthew? No contest there. Centennial Charmed - "The Painted World" just wasn't the memorable, plus this had Paige and it had Cole and it was just all around a million times better than TPW. |
|
|
|
Post by Xenith on Mar 27, 2008 0:49:48 GMT -5
Prue Halliwell Bracket
Andy Trudeau Regionals: First Round [/center] Something Wicca This Way Comes Bride and GloomSiren's SongCentennial Charmed Not one of my favorite episodes due to what I consider a highly dissapointing weak ending. (An climax based on an Alt. Reality Phoebe processing she isn't in love with Cole and him trying to persuade her otherwise. The lack of tthe real Phoebe being there killed a lot of this scenes impact, and if they couldn't have real Phoebe present the least they could of done was let Cole have a noble death...blah. Still as a whole the idea behind CC was good and made for an entertaining ep as a whole, while Painted although it doesn't have any moments that irritate me like that as a whole is kind of dull. |
|
|
|
Post by Drama on Mar 27, 2008 1:09:58 GMT -5
Prue Halliwell Bracket
Andy Trudeau Regionals: First Round Something Wicca This Way Comes
Bride and Gloom
Siren's Song
The Painted WorldCC really bothered me. Worst 100th episode any show could ask for. Plus, I liked Phoebe's smart spell. hehe |
|
{=}http://s2.images.proboards.com/tongue.gif{/=}
